Sunday, July 6, 2008

Brand Value

Its been almost a year since I began doing my Masters in Mass Communication at AJK Mass Communication Research Centre, Delhi. Opting for a course I was confident of not doing has proven to have benefited me the most. This was the only University I had applied for, because of its brand name and peer pressure. I was convinced of not getting through for my entrance exam was not that great! However, destiny had other plans. I cleared the entrance test, the interview and took admissions in the one of the premiere institute for Mass communication in Asia.

My dad has been in a transferable job ever since my childhood and I have spent my life living in Bangalurru, Chennai and Mumbai. Delhi has been my longest stay so far. In all these years except for The Hindu School in Chennai, I have never been in ‘well-known’ schools. When it was time for college, I couldn’t manage to get into the Ivy league college’s thanks to my 12 examination scores. Having said that I must admit that I consider each educational institution I have been a part of to be ‘The Best’ irrespective of its standing in society. I have had the privilege to be tutored by some great teachers who have been instrumental in tapping my talent, honing it and subsequently providing me with a platform thus exposing me to newer avenues. So when I got through Jamia, I admit that I was happy, but not overjoyed. Some-where I was puzzled if I was doing the right thing by taking up the course and opting out of a job at the Economic Times. I had high expectations from my batch-mates and infrastructure of the college, which has consequently turned out as per expectations.Soon after a month of joining Jamia, I understood what I would have missed had I left out on this opportunity. All my peers congratulating me, my teachers(ex-students of the same institute) assuring me about my right decision still flash my senses.

On the other hand, it is equally interesting to recall how people (read HINDU neighbours) reacted to this. “Isn’t it a Muslim University?”” Will you be comfortable amidst such a restrictive environment?”; “Won’t it be difficult for you to mingle with the crowd there?” In spite of my constant re-assurance that MCRC(as we fondly call it) is a ‘modern’ institute admitting even non-muslim students and giving them all the freedom that they would otherwise crave for, they would remain doubtful. Finally I had no choice but to say what I hate saying the most “Barkha Dutt, Kiran Rao, Harsh Chhaya, Roshan Abbas, Shah-Rukh Khan are all from my college” It worked and hmm…. suddenly Jamia regained its respect in their eyes.

What irks me the most is -Why is it that the success of students becomes the only yardstick to judge the standard of an educational institution? Why do people fail to recognize the worth of the institution minus the starry glamour of students? My school in Delhi-‘Delhi Kannada School’ may not have produced politicians, actors or CEO’s for that matter! But yes it has produced students who have the will and motivation to work hard in any given work-place, to stand up for truth and honesty. I therefore see no reason why I shouldn’t celebrate having belonged to an institution which has produced Mr. Sunil Khurana, Dr. Indira, Mr. Venkatesh, Ms Mandal and many others who are shining in the corporate world, healing their patients, fighting against injustice or simply teaching?.

I have witnessed parents cry foul over the teaching methods adopted in so called ‘reputed’ schools. What parents don’t realise is that a good school is not just about its fancy building, plush flooring, or its huge area!. Its more about the teachers and their teaching methods. I am not saying that all ‘reputed schools are bad’. Of course not!. Had this been the case they wouldn’t have attained that status in the first place. But I feel its high time that we look beyond the glitz and glamour quotient and acknowledge what really matters!

6 comments:

Anonymous said...

truly superb piecie...i guess people like us are the children of lesser known God...but in the end the truth is God is One..whatever form He might be.....keep writing good stuff...so that i get to comment on it..
p.s. the flow of thought still needs to be streamlined...

Anonymous said...

I know, I wanted to say some-thing else, but ended up writing on an all-together different issue. thanx for the comments and keep them coming:)

Voiceover said...

Dear Reena,

I happen to be one of the students whose names you mentioned. Honestly what does an institution do. It moulds and shapes people. We all step out into the world and try and carve a name and a place for ourselves. Yes a few get celebrated and celebritized but then its like the 10% face that the institute presents by its acheivements by while the 90% is happening behind the scenes.

I was a Jamia student who did not attend classes, argued for commercial ventures instead of change the world ventures. Loved some classes hated the others. But today I am proud to say I am from MCRC Jamia. It gave me 2 years to experiment with a medium. When you go out, that chance is taken away suddenly when the money versus output versus time equation kicks in.

Institutions celebrate their students like parents do a child who willingly mouths a poetry publicly and gets applauded for it. We are those lucky/unlucky children who elocute publicly for a living everyday.

Reena Manjrekar said...

Hey voiceover, firstly, thanks a lot for dropping by:) Felt great to listen to a senior. I do realise that in the field, what will matter will be just my work and talent and not the BRAND MCRC!

Anonymous said...

hi reena,

this is a late one to you.But just happened to come across your write up on your irritation that you had to use certain names to etablish the institutions credibility!

i happen to be one of the names mentioned... ;-).

it felt nice to know myself 'that' way! out here ...we have no clue about all that,all we are trying is to get up and go to work and hope the day will push us further in our lives...trying to elbow our way out of the crowd...get somewhere up the stack.
Does our name make a difference?...out here in the 'market'...a Zilch !
coz against a one from 'one of the best instiutions in asia'..here you meet the rest who are from the rest of the best instiutions of the world...and some plain fortunate..and some simply smart..and we are just one of them...and even though you seem to be irritated, to read what you have written was like "ah..some shade!" !
make the best of two years that you get there coz' it IS one of the best institutions that i know of in our field, all the exposure...facilities...and time that you get there to nurture yourself is simply amazing..and do keep in mind that THAT is time you get to plan your 'life outside'..thats one thing a lot of us miss out on ...all too protected and pampered in there...lost in all those little practicles...the AV..the radio programming...the four hundred feet film etc etc...and at times making too much of it if something works out fine!ok thats it...CUT!getting too long and sounding 'uncle' types! relating to a student of the same institution..guess the emotion takes the better of you!
i was not too fond of the'bunuel,goddard,ray' film weeks and bunked communication theory ! was the most sincere student of the 'graphics' class...and flunked it !! Now , you know something that your neighbours do'nt know!!and hey..mine was the last batch to get the monthly stipend, i believe! ;-)

Reena Manjrekar said...

Firstly I am glad to get a response from you. Well...I wasn't irritated taking those names, but rather frustrated of convincing people about an institution like Jamia!!(that was what the original post was meant to be about!)However, I digressed and delved into an altogether different territory:(

Nevertheless, your take on the 'world outside' was very insightful. I never actually thought of it that way.

Coming back to your 'graphics' paper do u mean Prof Lochan's lectures? If yes then, let me tell you that he now teaches us what's called 'Visual Communication'. Trust me...he has NEVERRRRRRRR liked my work. But I too am proud to say that I have not missed a single class of his:)And he continues to inspire me...:))
I have enjoyed Comm theory equally.

The second year is getting even more stimulating!. With Ms Shohini Ghosh, Prof Diwakar, Sabina Kidwai and Sabina Gadihoke as teachers, I don't think I'll EVER REGRET being a part of MCRC!

Once again thanks a ton for dropping by. Felt great to hear from a senior who didn't sound 'Uncle types':)